RELIGIOUS PLURALISM:THE INFLUENCE OF RATIONALISM AND RELATIVISM ON MUSLIM SCHOLARS

M. Adib Fuadi Nuriz, Jaffari Awang (2016) Religious Pluralism:the Influence Of Rationalism And Relativism On Muslim Scholars

Lembaga Penelitian Um Metro


File Pdf Download


ABSTRACT

The discourse of religious pluralism at this time has an impact on the current Islamic thought. This ideology has been bribed religious doctrine that considers differences caused a fight, seeing that sacred of religion could produce religious fundamen talism which makes religious fundamentalism seems to be exclusive of other religions. This ideology tries to give asolution of the conflict between religion, creating harmony and religious tolerance. However, religious pluralism resistance from various religious scholars because of this ideology insists of rationalism and relativism. This study investigates the question of re lig ious pluralism that is based on the philosophy of relativism and rationalism. The study is literature research using a critical an alysis. The results of this study found that religious pluralism promoted by Leibniz, Russell, John Locke, and John Hick has b een based on the philosophy of rationalism and relativism to interpret the meaning of relative and equal. It was influenced to the Isla mic thought of Muslim Scholar like Fritjhof Schuon, Rene Guenon, Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Fazlur Rahman and Murod Hoffman as Islamic inclusivism theology; theology which believes that Islam is a universal religion that accepts diversity and differenc es. Nurcholish Madjidideas of inclusivism also built the systematic methodologies that are capable of interpretation of Islam as a global understanding and agree with contemporary issues. It will be concludesin finding the strong influences of western pluralism in Islamic thought.

Keywords : Religious Pluralism, Relativism, Rationalism, Tolerance, Inclusivism

REFERENSI

[1]. Abu Rabi‟, Christian - Muslim Relations in Indonesia: The Challenges of The Twenty - First Century , Jurnal StudiaIslamika (Jakarta: IAIN SyarifHidayatullah, 1998). [2]. Abu Zayd, Nasr Hamid, HaakadzaTakallamaIbn „Araby (Cairo: al - Mathba‟a h al - Aamah Lil Kitab, 2002) [3]. Al - Banna, Jamal, al - Ta‟addudiyah al - Diniyyah fi - l - Mujtama‟ al - Islami (Cairo, DarulFikr, 2001). [4]. Ali, FachrydanBachtiar Effendi, MerambahJalanBaru Islam RekonstruksiPemikiran Islam MasaordeBaru (Bandung: Mizan, 1992). [5]. Anis Malik T hoha, “WacanaKebenaran Agama dalamPerspektif Islam (TelaahKritisGagasanPluralisme Agama)” , Makalah (Malang: UMM, 2005). [6]. Boase, Roger (ed), Religious Pluralism and the persuit of peace (London: Ashgate Publishing House, 2005). [7]. Coward, ”Religious Pluralism a nd the Future of Religions” dalam Thomas Dean (ed), Religious Pluralism and Truth Essays on Cross Cultural Philosophy of Religion (State University of New York Press, 1995). [8]. Coward, PluralismedanTantangan Agama - Agama, (Yogyakarta: Kanisius, 1989) THE 1 st ICONLEE The First International Conference on Law, Economics and Education Muhammadiyah Univer sity of Metro, Indonesia 22 │EDUCATION [9]. Dokumen Konsili Vatikan II (terj) R. Hardawiryana, SJ, (Jakarta: Obor, 1993). [10]. Hamami Zada, “Agama danEtnis: TantanganPluralisme di Indonesia” dalamSururindan Maria Ulfa (ed), Nilai - NilaiPluralismedalam Islam (Jakarta: Nuansa - Fatayat NU - Ford Foundation, 2006). [11]. Haru n Hadiwijono , Sari SejarahFilsafat Barat , Jilid 2 (Jakarta: Kanisius, 1980). [12]. Haryatmoko, Pluralisme Agama dalamPerspektifFilsafat , Diktat KuliahFilsafatIlmu (Yogyakarta: PPS IAIN SunanKalijaga, 1999). [13]. Legenhausen, Dr. Muhammad, Satu Agama atauBanyak Agama; KajiantentangLiberalismedanPluralisme Agama (Jakarta: PenerbitLentera, 2002). [14]. _________, Islam and Religious pluralism , terjemahArifMulyadidan Ana Farida (Jakarta: LenteraBasritama, 2002). [15]. M. Zainuddin, FilsafatIlmu: PerspektifPemikiran Islam (Jakarta: Li ntasPustaka, 2006). [16]. Madjid, Nurcholish, et.al., FiqhLintas Agama: MembangunMaysrakatInklusif - Pluralis (Jakarta: YayasanWaqafParamadinabekerjasamadengan The Asia Foundation, 2004), 207. Bandingkandengan Jamal al - Bana, Al - Ta‟addudiyyah fi MujtamaIslamy (Kairo : Dar al - Fikr al - Ismay, 2001). [17]. _________, Islam Doktrin dan Peradaban (Jakarta: Paramadina, 1992). [18]. _________, Khazanah Intelektual Islam (Jakarta: BulanBintang, 1984). [19]. _________, Pintu - pintuMenujuTuhan (Jakarta: Paramadina, 1994). [20]. Muhyar Fanani, “Mewujudka n Dunia Damai: Studi atas Sejarah Ide Pluralisme Agama dan Nasionalisme di Barat‟ dalam Ijtihad, JurnalWacanaHukum Islam (Salatiga: P3M STAIN Salatiga, 2003). [21]. Mulia, SitiMusdah, dalamsururin (ed ), Nilai - nilaiPluralismedalam Islam , (Bandung: Fatayat NU dan The Ford Foundation, 2005). [22]. Robert C. Solomon danKatheleen M. Higgins , Sari SejarahFilsafat, terj.SautPasaribu (Yogyakarta: YayasanBentengBudaya, 2002). [23]. Sachedina, Abdul Azis, The Islamic Roots of Democratic Pluralism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001 ) [24]. Sumbulah, “Islam RadikaldanPluralisme Agama: StudiKonstruksiSosialAktivisHizbutTahrirdanMajlis Mujahidin di Malang tentang Agama Kristen danYahudi”, Disertasi (Surabaya: IAIN SunanAmpel, 2006).